MAC Haute and naughty waterproof mascara

Haute and naughty waterproof mascara launched 2015. Yay or nay? For me defiantly yay. 

I have next to nothing natural lashes so I am always looking for something that will make them look thicker. The length doesn't really bother me as I have medium length on the top and as for the bottom, well don't hold your breath! 

After 2 layers this was my result. It stayed on which was good, I didn't have any smudges at the end of the day or look like a panda. 

To remove it however you have to use makeup remover solution because this does not want to come off!